Ayyubid

The Cession of Jerusalem by Treaty

Al-Kamil and Frederick II make terms, 1229 CE

626 AH / 1229 CE

Imagined 360° reconstruction of The Cession of Jerusalem by TreatyEducational historical reconstruction

Where

Jerusalem (al-Quds), in Palestine

31.7780, 35.2354 · View on OpenStreetMap

Background

In 1229, during the curious and almost bloodless Crusade led by the excommunicate emperor Frederick II, the city of Jerusalem changed hands not by battle but by a treaty, the Treaty of Jaffa, between Frederick and the Ayyubid sultan of Egypt, al-Kamil (rahimahu Allah), the nephew of Salah al-Din. Al-Kamil, embroiled in dangerous rivalries with his brothers and kinsmen who divided the Ayyubid lands among them, and anxious to be free of the threat of Frederick's army and to gain the emperor as an ally, agreed to surrender Jerusalem and a corridor of territory to the Franks. By the terms, however, the sacred esplanade of the Haram al-Sharif, the noble sanctuary with the Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock, the first qibla and the third holiest place of Islam, was kept in Muslim hands and Muslim worship, with the Muslim officials and the call to prayer preserved there, while the rest of the city passed under Frankish control. The arrangement was condemned across the Muslim world: that the holy city, recovered with such struggle and sacrifice by Salah al-Din only forty years before, should be handed back to the unbelievers without a sword drawn, was felt as a grief and a disgrace, and the preachers and scholars of Damascus and elsewhere lamented it bitterly. Frederick's own position was scarcely better, condemned by the Pope and unloved by the Latins of the East. The cession proved short-lived: Jerusalem returned to Muslim rule within fifteen years, in 1244, when it was taken by the Khwarazmian troops allied to the Ayyubids of Egypt, and it would remain in Muslim hands thereafter for centuries. This scene depicts Jerusalem at the time of its cession by treaty, the Haram and the city. In keeping with the project's ethics any figure is anonymous and at a distance.

What you see

A walled holy city of pale stone on the Judaean hills, crowned by a great golden-domed shrine and a long silver-domed mosque rising over a broad sacred esplanade; the city holy to three faiths, the first qibla of Islam.

No siege rings the walls and no battle is fought; instead envoys go to and fro with documents and seals, for the city is changing hands not by the sword but by a treaty between a Muslim sultan and a Frankish emperor.

This is the cession of Jerusalem in 1229, when the Ayyubid sultan al-Kamil (rahimahu Allah), beset by rivalries within his own house, handed the city over to the emperor Frederick II by negotiation, keeping in Muslim hands only the sacred esplanade of the Haram with its mosque and shrine.

The sacred enclosure of al-Aqsa and the Dome of the Rock is reserved to the Muslims by the terms, with their worship and their officials, while the rest of the city passes to the Franks; an arrangement that satisfied few and dismayed many.

Across the Muslim world the news is met with grief and outrage that the holy city, won back with such sacrifice by Salah al-Din, has been given away without a fight; the deal is bitterly condemned, and it will last but fifteen years before Jerusalem returns to Muslim rule.

The Treaty of Jaffa of 1229 and the cession of Jerusalem are recorded in the chronicles. The scene depicts the holy city at the time of the treaty; no individual is shown by likeness.

Primary sources

Arabic chronicles of the Ayyubid period (Ibn al-Athir, Sibt ibn al-Jawzi, al-Maqrizi): Used for the treaty, al-Kamil's motives and the outrage in the Muslim world. Confidence high.

Further reading & cross-references

Accounts of the laments and condemnations at Damascus (Sibt ibn al-Jawzi's sermon): Used for the grief of the Muslim public at the cession. Confidence high.

Histories of the Sixth Crusade and Frederick II (cross-reference): Used for the Treaty of Jaffa, the terms and Frederick's position. Cross-reference. Confidence high.

Medieval Jerusalem and the Haram al-Sharif (material/geographic context): The walled city, the sanctuary, the Dome of the Rock and the Aqsa constrain the depiction.

Guess places like this in GeoSiyer

Drop into a 360° scene from Islamic history and pin where — and when — it happened.

Play GeoSiyer